DS: What do you think will happen if we remain in Iraq?
JC: Oh, I fear it is likely that we will in fact remain for years in one way or another. My own analysis is that the US military in the Sunni Arab areas has over time driven most Sunni Arabs into the arms of the guerrillas. A lot were on the fence in 2003. But green troops killed civilians of important tribes or busted down doors and went through women's underthings, and over time virtually all the Sunni Arabs came to hate us. Search and destroy is bad counter-insurgency. Now they are experimenting with "take and hold" and "oil spot" strategies, but they just look like larger-scale search and destroy missions to me. (Tal Afar is an example, attacked by the US and Iraqi government troops in August, 2005, and given out as a success story. It doesn't appear to me anything of the sort.) If US military counter-insurgency were succeeding, it would be apparent in better security. It clearly is not succeeding.
So, if we stay in these kind of numbers, I think more and more Iraqis will take up arms against us.
DS: What do you think will happen if we pull out?
JC: If we pull out, the Sunni Arab guerrillas will turn their efforts full-time to overthrowing the new Iraqi government and taking the Green Zone. That development spells Sunni-Shiite civil war. Moreover, there is danger of an Iraqi civil war drawing in Iran, Saudi Arabia and Turkey, so that it becomes a regional guerrilla war.
DS: Is there a solution, and what do you think will become of Iraq?
JC: The crisis in Iraq just has to be internationalized. The Italians are leaving, and probably most of the rest of the coalition will be gone by the end of the year. The British will draw down substantially and therefore become much weaker and reactive. There is no evidence that the Iraqi military or security forces can effectively substitute for the foreign troops in the hot spots, though they are good enough for places like Samawah and Najaf.
The political process has not in fact drawn in the Sunni Arabs. Mostly the political class of that community is deeply unhappy with the new government and its place in it. The guerrilla movement has gone from strength to strength and there is no sign that it is being effectively combatted. There is some danger of it taking over the Sunni Arab heartland as US troops withdraw.
A Salafi Jihadi mini-state in north-central and western Iraq is not acceptable to any of the neighbors, and they should be enlisted to stop it. Likewise, the new interest of the Malaysian PM and the Organization of the Islamic Conference in helping Iraq should be jumped on with alacrity.
But I am not optimistic. I think the likelihood is that either Iraq will descend into a Yugoslavia-type maelstrom with much death and destruction and a break-up into mini-states as a result; or it will descend into a Lebanon-type maelstrom with much death and destruction but manage to come back together as a weak nation-state in the end. The second is the better outcome for the region and the world, but it is not guaranteed. Both scenarios are dire, and could spin out of control into regional conflagration.
Clearly, there are no good options at this point, so we have to figure out which is the least bad option, which seems to be bringing in an international force to provide a modicum of security while the Iraqi government attempts to establish itself. Unfortunately, that also seems like the least likeliest possibility right now.
At this moment, "staying the course" is probably what will prevail until 2009, at which time it might be possible (certainly it must be tried) for a Democratic administration (if the President we elect is smart enough and crafty enough) to cut through the animosity that's been built up towards us and put together the kind of real international coalition that should have been prosecuting any action in Iraq in the first place. Once that's in place, we can gradually withdraw. This option is denied the Bush administration due to both their incompetency and their ideological predisposition against multilateralism and international cooperation.
By invading Iraq the way he did, Bush threw us all off a cliff, and we continue to fall. There's no question that eventually we are going to hit the ground, and that the landing is going to be hard -- the only question is exactly how hard.
absolutist
aggresive
anti-Constitutional
anti-intellectual
arrogant
authoritarian
blame-placers
blameworthy
blinkered
buckpassers
calculating
class warriors
clueless
compassionless
con artists
conniving
conscienceless
conspiratorial
corrupt
craven
criminal
crooked
culpable
damaging
dangerous
deadly
debased
deceitful
delusional
despotic
destructive
devious
disconnected
dishonorable
dishonest
disingenuous
disrespectful
dogmatic
doomed
fanatical
fantasists
felonious
hateful
heinous
hostile to science
hypocritical
ideologues
ignorant
immoral
incompetent
indifferent
inflexible
insensitive
insincere
irrational
isolated
kleptocratic
lacking in empathy
lacking in public spirit
liars
mendacious
misleading
mistrustful
non-rational
not candid
not "reality-based"
not trustworthy
oblivious
oligarchic
opportunistic
out of control
pernicious
perverse
philistine
plutocratic
prevaricating
propagandists
rapacious
relentless
reprehensible
rigid
scandalous
schemers
selfish
secretive
shameless
sleazy
tricky
unAmerican
uncaring
uncivil
uncompromising
unconstitutional
undemocratic
unethical
unpopular
unprincipled
unrealistic
unreliable
unrepresentative
unscientific
unscrupulous
unsympathetic
venal
vile
virtueless
warmongers
wicked
without integrity
wrong-headed
Thanks to: Breeze, Chuck, Ivan Raikov, Kaiju, Kathy, Roger, Shirley, S.M. Dixon
recently seen
i've got a little list...
Elliott Abrams
Steven Abrams (Kansas BofE)
David Addington
Howard Fieldstead Ahmanson
Roger Ailes (FNC)
John Ashcroft
Bob Bennett
William Bennett
Joe Biden
John Bolton
Alan Bonsell (Dover BofE)
Pat Buchanan
Bill Buckingham (Dover BofE)
George W. Bush
Saxby Chambliss
Bruce Chapman (DI)
Dick Cheney
Lynne Cheney
Richard Cohen
The Coors Family
Ann Coulter
Michael Crichton
Lanny Davis
Tom DeLay
William A. Dembski
James Dobson
Leonard Downie (WaPo)
Dinesh D’Souza
Gregg Easterbrook
Jerry Falwell
Douglas Feith
Arthur Finkelstein
Bill Frist
George Gilder
Newt Gingrich
John Gibson (FNC)
Alberto Gonzalez
Rudolph Giuliani
Sean Hannity
Katherine Harris
Fred Hiatt (WaPo)
Christopher Hitchens
David Horowitz
Don Imus
James F. Inhofe
Jesse Jackson
Philip E. Johnson
Daryn Kagan
Joe Klein
Phil Kline
Ron Klink
William Kristol
Ken Lay
Joe Lieberman
Rush Limbaugh
Trent Lott
Frank Luntz
"American Fundamentalists"
by Joel Pelletier
(click on image for more info)
Chris Matthews
Mitch McConnell
Stephen C. Meyer (DI)
Judith Miller (ex-NYT)
Zell Miller
Tom Monaghan
Sun Myung Moon
Roy Moore
Dick Morris
Rupert Murdoch
Ralph Nader
John Negroponte
Grover Norquist
Robert Novak
Ted Olson
Elspeth Reeve (TNR)
Bill O'Reilly
Martin Peretz (TNR)
Richard Perle
Ramesh Ponnuru
Ralph Reed
Pat Robertson
Karl Rove
Tim Russert
Rick Santorum
Richard Mellon Scaife
Antonin Scalia
Joe Scarborough
Susan Schmidt (WaPo)
Bill Schneider
Al Sharpton
Ron Silver
John Solomon (WaPo)
Margaret Spellings
Kenneth Starr
Randall Terry
Clarence Thomas
Richard Thompson (TMLC)
Donald Trump
Richard Viguere
Donald Wildmon
Paul Wolfowitz
Bob Woodward (WaPo)
John Yoo
guest-blogging
All the fine sites I've
guest-blogged for:
Be sure to visit them all!!
recent listening
influences
John Adams
Laurie Anderson
Aphex Twin
Isaac Asimov
Fred Astaire
J.G. Ballard
The Beatles
Busby Berkeley
John Cage
"Catch-22"
Raymond Chandler
Arthur C. Clarke
Elvis Costello
Richard Dawkins
Daniel C. Dennett
Philip K. Dick
Kevin Drum
Brian Eno
Fela
Firesign Theatre
Eliot Gelwan
William Gibson
Philip Glass
David Gordon
Stephen Jay Gould
Dashiell Hammett
"The Harder They Come"
Robert Heinlein
Joseph Heller
Frank Herbert
Douglas Hofstadter
Bill James
Gene Kelly
Stanley Kubrick
Jefferson Airplane
Ursula K. LeGuin
The Marx Brothers
John McPhee
Harry Partch
Michael C. Penta
Monty Python
Orbital
Michael Powell & Emeric Pressburger
"The Prisoner"
"The Red Shoes"
Steve Reich
Terry Riley
Oliver Sacks
Erik Satie
"Singin' in the Rain"
Stephen Sondheim
The Specials
Morton Subotnick
Talking Heads/David Byrne
Tangerine Dream
Hunter S. Thompson
J.R.R. Tolkien
"2001: A Space Odyssey"
Kurt Vonnegut
Yes
Bullshit, trolling, unthinking knee-jerk dogmatism and the drivel of idiots will be ruthlessly deleted and the posters banned.
Entertaining, interesting, intelligent, informed and informative comments will always be welcome, even when I disagree with them.
I am the sole judge of which of these qualities pertains.
E-mail
All e-mail received is subject to being published on unfutz without identifying names or addresses.
Corrections
I correct typos and other simple errors of grammar, syntax, style and presentation in my posts after the fact without necessarily posting notification of the change.
Substantive textual changes, especially reversals or major corrections, will be noted in an "Update" or a footnote.
Also, illustrations may be added to entries after their initial publication.
the story so far
unfutz: toiling in almost complete obscurity for almost 1500 days
If you read unfutz at least once a week, without fail, your teeth will be whiter and your love life more satisfying.
If you read it daily, I will come to your house, kiss you on the forehead, bathe your feet, and cook pancakes for you, with yummy syrup and everything.
(You might want to keep a watch on me, though, just to avoid the syrup ending up on your feet and the pancakes on your forehead.)
Finally, on a more mundane level, since I don't believe that anyone actually reads this stuff, I make this offer: I'll give five bucks to the first person who contacts me and asks for it -- and, believe me, right now five bucks might as well be five hundred, so this is no trivial offer.